I used to love watching The Ellery Queen Mysteries on NBC when I was a kid. Mom and I would watch as Jim Hutton and David Wayne portrayed the father and son pair; one a police inspector, the other an amazing detective. Each episode would end with Ellery solving the case and just before the reveal, he would break the fourth wall and talk to the audience, pointing out important clues and asking leading questions. It was a lot of fun to watch and to play along.
The Mandarin Mystery was billed on box as an Ellery Queen mystery. I was curious how a cinematic Queen might turn out, so I decided to pop the disc into the player and check it out. The disc was part of a 2 disc, 4 movie set in the AMC DVD collection. This collection was Great Detectives and included Sherlock Holmes along with Bulldog Drummond and Mr. Moto. The character of Ellery Queen was played by Eddie Quillan and he plays Queen as a very confident, and very excitable young man. He’s also very intelligent and has an eye for the ladies. He immediately takes notice of Josephine Temple (Charlotte Henry) a young woman who has arrived to sell a very rare and valuable stamp to a collector named Dr. Kirk. Dr. Kirk collects stamps and has been investing his ward’s inheritance into the hobby since the values continue to rise. This allows him to pursue his hobby while investing her money as well. The problem is she doesn’t approve, and she has others in the Kirk family that don’t feel this is a proper use of her money either. When Josephine gets to the hotel where Dr. Kirk is staying, the stamp is stolen from her. Soon a murder has taken place as well, and it is up to Ellery and his dad to figure it out.
One way to make a mystery harder to figure out is to throw in a large collection of suspects, and that is what the writers do here. They provide a few clues and a bunch of red herrings before eventually Ellery puts all the pieces together. I enjoyed the film, but I do wish they had cut back just a little on the peripheral characters. We not only have Miss Temple, Dr. Kirk, and the two Kirk girls, but there’s a boyfriend, a forger, and a stamp expert. It soon becomes hard to remember everyone’s purpose and motive.
The print from which the transfer was made had some issues as well. One scene jumps around like the print had sprocket damage when it went through the machine. Still for $3, I don’t feel I got burned too bad. The film plays fairly well with the exception of that one spot. It still would have been nice to have had a cleaned-up and remastered print.
I give The Mandarin Mystery 2 1/2 stars. I wish Quillan had done some other Queen films, but sadly this appears to have been his only outing as Ellery Queen. Most of the other Queen films I have looked up feature Ralph Bellamy. On a side note, I also just saw where the Ellery Queen Mysteries television show with Jim Hutton is coming to DVD this month. Looks like I have something to shop for.